Reviews

Based on 1764 reviews
90%
(1588)
6%
(113)
1%
(25)
1%
(14)
1%
(24)
Height: 5’10
Weight: 170
Fit: Runs Small
Size Bought: 2 (M)
Didn’t fit correctly

Had to return them. Fit great in the body, but the arms were way too tight. Still waiting on my refund, never mind the $50 bet.

Height: 5’8
Weight: 160
Fit: True to Size
Size Bought: 2 (M)
Size Normally Worn : M
Best T-shirt ever

I’ve bought many T-shirt’s to wear under blazers or with jeans etc and nothing compares to this. I bought a white and black. The material and fit are amazing. Great length too. Home run purchase. Other brands of this quality charge double. I made my friend by one when he asked me about mine! I also own 4 button downs. Great stuff!!!

Height: 5'11
Weight: 170
Fit: True to Size
Size Bought: 2 (M)
Size Normally Worn : M
Bought it for my man, will definitely be getting more!!

This shirt is a HUGE win!!! In multiple areas.
1. My man has discerning taste and buying him something that he doesn't return is a rarity (no fault there, I am similar), this shirt was not returned.
2. I have been sewing for 30+ years. I took lesson in tailoring and couture. I did alterations for awhile. I have custom designed and altered dresses for other (causal to wedding). I now create my own clothes (I have a more vintage style, 40-50s fashion) and I wanted my amazing man (who also has a build I admire) to have a shirt that fit all his needs, like I know a shirt should. I wanted to create a custom shirt, but we both work full time and I couldn't make it happen. I just knew once he experienced what it was like to wear a shirt designed for his physique he would never go back. I knew how it needed to fit and this shirt design does it all! I will only have to adjust sleeve length by 1/2 inch to make it perfect for him, that is a a minor aspect, and it still very wearable as is.
3. The collar design is ingenious! This shirt highlights my man's features so much that I look forward to admiring at him while we're out (may be difficult to get places on time though because he looks delicious). The fabric is divine to touch and the zipper is a wonderful addition!
4. I am thrilled to give my man something that honors/values how much he does for me/us in all levels of our relationship. I now have a gift that will never fail. Thank you!

Height: 5'8"
Weight: 200
Fit: True to Size
Size Bought: 4 (L)
Size Normally Worn : M
Comfortable and fits well

I used the sizing tool and it gave me the correct sizing. The shirt is comfortable, fits well, looks great. The zipper can be a little difficult to work, but I haven't really had time to get used to it so it'll probably get better.

The Pique Shirt <br> Small Batch Series

A
The Pilot Shirt
Anna McCann
Height: 170cm
Weight: 63kg
Fit: Runs Large
Size Bought: 1 (S)
Size Normally Worn : S
Not a good fit for an athletic body

My husband is a professional acrobat with wide shoulders/ large chest and a tiny waist, and it is hard to find shirts that fit him well (usually he always has to have them tailored), so I had high hopes for TS when I ordered this for his Christmas present. He is quite short and usually a size S, which TS customer service confirmed based on his measurements. However, the Pilot shirt was extremely baggy on him and the sleeves were long and also very wide. The shoulder width was perfect. I explained this and sent pictures to customer service and asked if it was worth trying the size below or if the shoulders would be too small. They said to try XS. I got the stretch poplin in XS thinking that maybe the stretchy material would also work better. However, this was way too small on the shoulders and the sleeves were too short, whilst it was still baggy on the waist. Now I am having to return the shirt again. I wish that, instead of recommending the smaller size which was so much smaller on the shoulders, customer service had suggested the $50 rebate that I just saw in small print (in case the shirt is not a perfect fit but you still want to keep it). We would have kept the first shirt and used the $50 to have it tailored to be a true slim fit. Now I've wasted a bunch of time with exchanges and returns +postage fee and am back to square one with no xmas present for hubby. I like the idea of the zipper and the quality seems good, the fit just didn't live up to my expectations at all.

Height: 5'-11"
Weight: 170
Fit: Runs Small
Size Bought: 3 (M|L)
Size Normally Worn : XL

love the style and would like to see in more color choices. seems to run small in the overall compared to other stratford shirts I own. the sleeves most of all were short on me, but overall the style is dead on.

D
The NYTD
Dave W
Height: 5'10"
Weight: 145
Fit: True to Size
Size Bought: 1 (S)
Size Normally Worn : S
Very much worth it

I never thought I'd be writing a review about a shirt, OR that I would pay this much for a shirt -- BUT these TS shirts are really amazing. I'm a slim and fit guy, 5' 10", and pretty much every other dress shirt brand either poofs out in the wrong places or gaps at the chest. TS shirts solve both of those problems AND they have great materials, design and quality. Not to mention the clever collar stay design. I love that they can be worn tucked-in or untucked and look great either way. Definitely my new favorite shirts!

Love to read this at least as much as you love your new shirt!

Height: 6’
Weight: 187
Fit: True to Size
Size Bought: 3 (M|L)
Size Normally Worn : L

It fit really well. There was no gaping at the chest which is his usual issue. He’s only tried it on, haven’t had an occasion to wear it out yet, but we’re happy with it!

Height: 6’3 and 1/2 inches
Weight: 260
Fit: Runs Small
Size Bought: 6 (XXL)
Size Normally Worn : XXL
CAN’T WEAR IT

I’m a big man and usually wear a 2XL. I ordered a 6XXL and it’s much too small to fit. Very disappointed.

Sorry that the shirt didn't work out for you. Our size 6 is like an XXL but our shirt is athletic cut and tapers to a slimmer waist. A XXL in other brands will be much roomier in the waist by the nature of the different cut and this is often the issue for bigger guys. We are adding a XXXL to the size run this year so that more guys can wear our shirts and we hope that this size will fit you.

Fit: Runs Small
Size Bought: 6 (XXL)
Size Normally Worn : XXL

Not close to fitting

Height: 5’11
Weight: 185
Fit: Runs Small
Size Bought: 5 (XL)
Size Normally Worn : L
Zip up flannel

My husband loves these shirts. They fit so nice.

Fit: True to Size
Size Bought: 2 (M)
Size Normally Worn : M
love the shirt

nice fabric
excellent fit

Height: 6’0”
Weight: 172
Fit: True to Size
Size Bought: 2 (M)
Size Normally Worn : M
Very satisfied

Very nice quality, thick, sturdy material. Worn a couple times and got compliments each time. Have not washed yet but will follow instructions and hope it maintains its quality. I expect so based on price.

Height: 6'1
Weight: not sure. But my guy is tall and lanky
Fit: True to Size
Size Bought: 4 (L)
Size Normally Worn : XL
The perfect gift for my dude!

I gifted this for my guy for Christmas and I'm SO glad I did because it was PERFECT. Its such a cool style and great fit. The TS shirt really does do all thats promised. Its an athletic fit but you don't have to be 'athletic' to wear it. The way it's cut fits all body types and even though my dude is perfect in my eyes, he may not feel perfect in his and he feels really confident wearing this style and cut. Plus the plaid - super sexy and stylish. I love seeing him wear it, which is does a lot because it just looks great on him and he says it feels perfect. Highly recommended. Plus the guys at TS are super awesome. I told them I was unsure about the size and they said they'd happily exchange it no questions asked if it wasn't the best fit for my guy. Super happy with my purchase and so is my dude <3 @jennasadventures

Love to read this! Making dudes look and feel great is our mission. Thank you for taking the time to review!

L
The Varsity Oxford
Lois Quinn-Ortiz
Height: 6'
Weight: 190
Fit: Runs Small
Size Bought: 4 (L)
Size Normally Worn : L
Sizing problematic

We love these shirts, but XL is too big and L is a bit snug.

We make our sizes so that there isn’t a lot of space between them and people don’t get caught like it sounds like you are. Suggestion would be to take the larger size and expose it to heat in the dryer. It should shrink about 1/2 size.

N
The Varsity Oxford
Nichole Arnett
Height: 6'4
Weight: 230
Fit: True to Size
Size Bought: 5 (XL)
Size Normally Worn : XL
impressed

The fit is fantastic. My husband is tall and athletically built, so when we tried on the shirts, we were really delighted with the quality and fit, which is designed for a tall fit figure.

Height: 6'1"
Weight: 190
Fit: Runs Small
Size Bought: 3 (M|L)
Size Normally Worn : L
Nice shirt, runs small

Shirt is as advertised, runs a tad small across the back of the shoulders

Height: 6’1”
Weight: 175
Fit: True to Size
Size Bought: 3 (M|L)
Size Normally Worn : M
Makes your man look sharp

This shirt makes your man look sharp. Fits perfect. Taylored without being too tight. Great color and pattern selection.

P
The NYTD Flannel- Small Batch Series
Patti Cascio these shirts did not fit at all and and no refund I would say scam
Fit: Runs Small
Size Bought: 4 (L)
Size Normally Worn : L

Terrible- the size didn’t even close to fit and they response to refund was never reviewed. Still waiting for them to respond

Hi Patti- We spoke with you via text and hope that everything has been resolved with your returns/exchanges. A 'scam' is not something our company or products have been referred to before. If the shirt doesn't work for you we accept returns and exchanges on unworn/unwashed shirts.

The Gabardine

Fit: Runs Small
Size Bought: 2 (M)
Size Normally Worn : M

Mega Stretch Performance Broadcloth

Height: 5’9
Weight: 180
Fit: True to Size
Size Bought: 3 (M|L)
Size Normally Worn : M
Beautiful pattern, great material, but the customer service was the thing that will keep me shopp...

This was sort of an impulsive purchase that I happen to come upon and am so glad that I did. The shirts themselves are pretty innovative as they fit my husband’s (muscular athletic) body perfectly and do not leave gaps anywhere in the button seam. This is normally a problem as his biceps and back are giant and his waist is like a small child. The real MVP, though, was Bryan; he text me after I made the order to double check on size choices and I am SO glad he did. We ended up going one size up and they fit my husband perfectly. Couldn’t recommend enough as a company in general.

Thank you Jimena. We are happy to hear that you love our product and customer service!

Height: 6’3”
Weight: 220
Fit: True to Size
Size Bought: 5 (XL)
Size Normally Worn : XL
Great fit

Love the fit especially around the midsection.

Height: 5’5”
Weight: 125
Fit: True to Size
Size Bought: 0 (XS)
Size Normally Worn : XS
Luv me up some shirts

I purchased three of these as the patterns are swell, they fit well, and I love how sharp they make me look!

Love to read this!