Reviews

Based on 1969 reviews
88%
(1730)
7%
(133)
2%
(39)
1%
(28)
2%
(39)
Height: 6’2”
Weight: 155
Fit: True to Size
Size Bought: 1 (S)
Size Normally Worn : M
Shirt

Working out well.

Height: 5ft 10in
Weight: 190
Fit: True to Size
Size Bought: 3 (M|L)
Size Normally Worn : M
This was a perfect fit!

The mega stretch was absolutely perfect! I love the way it looks, and it was a perfect fit. The other one that I kept, I have to lose a drop of weight for. This one was absolutely perfect! The other one is the same size, but a different cut. I really love them both, and I can't wait to fit into the other one! And I'm still waiting on one more.. so you've got a customer! It's rare that I appreciate my online purchases! But I have that athletic fit which looks great standing up and then pops out when you're sitting down. Such an amazing and unbelievable idea that you guys came up with! Absolutely love my shirt! So many compliments on it as well! I love the colors days, the way it fits, the ability to wear a tie, or dress it down, and all the other potential wearing opportunities! Already spent like 350 bucks on your s***, and I plan to spend a lot more! Thank you!

Great to hear! One quick thing is that most of our shirts have the same cut/fit so there shouldn’t be much difference between shirts. The stretch does give the shirts a different feel and can seem like they are roomier than the non stretch. But in your case it looks like you ordered one shirt in a size smaller. The short sleeved one is a size 2 rather than a size 3. If that is the one that is feeling smaller then this is the reason.

Height: 6
Weight: 170
Fit: True to Size
Size Bought: 2 (M)
TS shirts are always 🌶️

Great shirt and fit as always. Keep them up the great work

S
The Dress Twill
Steven Matzinger
Height: 6-0
Weight: 236
Fit: Runs Small
Size Bought: 6 (XXL)
Size Normally Worn : XXL
To small

To small

We do free exchanges and have a size larger than the one you ordered. Just go to the following link: teddy-stratford.returnly.com

Height: 5'9
Weight: 205
Fit: True to Size
Size Bought: 4 (L)
Size Normally Worn : M
Looks great!

Fits comfortably and love that the shirt doesn't pop open. It has a great look and is warm enough where I live (sf) so that i can wear it in evenings or out. I have a bit of a gut and it keeps its shape great.

Height: 5’8”
Weight: 170
Fit: Runs Small
Size Bought: 3 (M|L)
Size Normally Worn : L
Fit

Rather tight

Do you think sizing up would work for you? We do free exchanges on unwashed/unworn shirts. You can do that from the following link: teddy-stratford.returnly.com

Height: 6'2"
Weight: 180
Fit: True to Size
Size Bought: 3 (M|L)
Size Normally Worn : L
Really a great shirt!

I have broad shoulders and most dress shirts pull across the chest. This shirt fit perfectly and even the sleeve length was just right. Will definitely purchase more.

R
The Aloha Shirt
Ralph Kimbrough
Height: 5’9”
Weight: 205
Fit: Runs Small
Size Bought: 3 (M|L)
Size Normally Worn : M
Uncomfortable shirt 😩😩😩

Sleeves don’t flex or stretch! I’m so disappointed because I was excited about this shirt. It’s very uncomfortable and restrictive.

It sounds like you may need a size larger than what you ordered. Since this is a warehouse sale item it is a final sale but reach out to custcare@teddystratford.com and we’ll see what we can do to get you a shirt you like.

Height: 6’4”
Weight: 230
Fit: True to Size
Size Bought: 5 (XL)
Size Normally Worn : XL
Great fit!

Not sure why I waited to purchase a Teddy Stratford. These shirts fit and look amazing

Height: 5'9"
Weight: 180
Fit: Runs Large
Size Bought: 4 (L)
Size Normally Worn : L
Wrong color and wrong fit.

I was under the impression that the shirt I ordered was black, not a dark navy. Also does not allow for much movement when you bring your arms up. When the shirt is pulled down, it fits alright. But when I raise my arms, it is very loose and large in the chest, but tight down by the waist and bottom button. I'm gonna have to hit the gym to make this fit just right or something. I gave all the correct measurements to the person who took my order as well.

Hi Noah- this shirt is a midnight blue as opposed to black. We do sell black shirts but not in this fabric. As far as sizing goes, it sounds like you may benefit from going one size down if the chest is too loose. Keep in mind that our shirt is athletic fit so it does taper to a slim waist. If the size you ordered feels too tight in the waist when you move around then going one size down may not be the best solution. We do free exchanges and returns so you can always try a black in the size below. We’d recommend the Mega Stretch if you want to do that.

J
The Dress Twill
Jim Herbert
Height: 5’6”
Weight: 190
Fit: Runs Small
Size Bought: 4 (L)
Size Normally Worn : L
Great fit

These shirts fit wonderfully and don’t “pooch out” all over. Stays nice even with lots of up and down or in and out of the car. I’ll never buy another kind of dress shirt.
A little pricey though.

Height: 5'11"
Weight: 220
Fit: True to Size
Size Bought: 4 (L)
Size Normally Worn : XL
Fantastic

This shirt fits tight and well around the chest and arms. If you work out, think Schmedium.

Height: 5'11"
Weight: 220
Fit: True to Size
Size Bought: 4 (L)
Size Normally Worn : XL
Fantastic

This shirt fits tight and well around the chest and arms. If you work out, think Schmedium.

Height: 5'11"
Weight: 220
Fit: True to Size
Size Bought: 4 (L)
Size Normally Worn : XL
Fantastic

This shirt fits tight and well around the chest and arms. If you work out, think Schmedium.

Height: 5'11
Weight: 195
Fit: True to Size
Size Bought: 4 (L)
Size Normally Worn : L

The best shirt on the market! The fit is just as advertised. The service and follow up is better than expected.

Height: 5'11"
Weight: 190
Fit: True to Size
Size Bought: 4 (L)
Size Normally Worn : L
Great Shirt!

I have broad shoulders and it fits them perfectly while tapering down to my thinner waste. Thank you! Finally, a shirt that fits!

Height: 6’6
Weight: 225
Fit: True to Size
Size Bought: 5 (XL)
Size Normally Worn : XXL
Wow!

What a great fitting shirt! Love how it accentuates my broad shoulders and slim waist!!

Love to see it!

Height: 5'6"
Weight: 142
Fit: True to Size
Size Bought: 1 (S)
Size Normally Worn : S
THE PERFECT SHIRT... ALMOST

Great shirt at a great price. Quality build & materials. Fit is among the best off-the-rack I've purchased... shoulder cut, waist taper, chest fit, sleeve length, body length, etc...Fantastic.

I like the zipper feature, but it's also the primary complaint I have about the shirt.

* When untucked - no issues. Great

* When tucked in to suit pants - the seam cloth that the zipper is sewn to tends to bubble. I wish there was a way to make the zipper fabric "less rigid" along the waist where the shirt tucks in and tends to fold over the waistline. Most of the time, the effect is that the shirts bubbles out and looks like a pot belly - particularly from the profile. Im just OCD enough that this is really bothersome.

If there has been any improvement to remedy this, or if anyone has found something to help reduce it, I'd love to know.

i
The Gingham Poplin
itBmeJC
Height: 6
Weight: 1
Fit: Runs Small
Size Bought: 4 (L)
Size Normally Worn : L
Good quality but fits very tight

I'm 6'1" 205lbs Ordered 2 4L and the shirts appeared to be good quality however they fit extremely tight especially the arms. The sleeves were so tight. The length was fine but the shirt was so tight in the arms. I feel like these shirts are made for a very lean body. My body fat +/- 18% so I'm not fat and I am not body builder lean. My feeling is that if you are that lean then why do you need a zippered shirt? I thought the zippered shirts sounded like a great idea but they just don't fit my body type

Thanks for taking the time to review. At your height/weight we’d have thought that a size 4 would work but the shirts are made to fit close to the body including the arms. If you think sizing up would work for you, exchanges are free.

Height: 6 feet
Weight: 125 lbs
Fit: True to Size
Size Bought: 0 (XS)
Size Normally Worn : M
Teddy Stratford Shirts Review

Great tailored fit, love the zipper, I show all my friends and they are like that’s so cool. Instead of just small, medium, and large, zip fit shirts have more tailored sizing. They are now my favorite colored shirt. I got the raider shirts’ in linen and they are the best for hot summers or environments.

Thanks for your review John

P
The Raider Shirt
Paul Schlader
Height: 5'9
Weight: 31
Fit: True to Size
Size Bought: 2 (M)
Size Normally Worn : M
Raider shirt Midnight Blue

I will be reordering multiple of this shirt when back in stock. I also purchased two of the linen ones and love them as well. These are well made and fit great!

Great to hear! The Midnight Raider shirt is one of our favorites too. We are adding a couple new colors to the Raider line this fall too so keep an eye out!

n
The NYTD
nick wooley
Height: 6’3”
Weight: 190
Fit: True to Size
Size Bought: 4 (L)
Size Normally Worn : L
Best Shirt Ever!

Just an awesome shirt. It makes you look better than you should lol. I have broad shoulders and strong arms, but I’m what you might call “skinny fat”. I’ve got a little pudge that I need to lose, but it hides it very well. Amazing fit. Accentuates the best features and hides the not so great. I will say that the website said I was a 3, but I would size up if you have any stomach fat. The size 4 is perfect.

Height: 5feet 8inchs
Weight: 176 pounds
Size Bought: 3 (M|L)

It is a nice design and fits perfectly, I like the zipper part and the collar!magnificent

Height: 75 inches
Weight: 230
Fit: True to Size
Size Bought: 5 (XL)
Size Normally Worn : XL

Great fit

sleeves are too long need 32 inch sleeve